I tweeted about a problem writers are facing. A seemingly ruthless and universal issue that shows no mercy. The problem? Misbehaving and disobedient fictitious characters.
#Writingcommunity, I’m going to be controversial. Is it just me or is it massively irritating when fellow writers talk about their loss of control over their own characters? It’s your character. Your universe. Your world. You’re in control. Thoughts? #writing #author pic.twitter.com/y3a5V35Ugr
— T. J. Blake (@TJBlake93) January 26, 2019
What is losing control over your character?
Many writers talk about occasions when their character does something that they (the writer) simply didn’t expect or allow.
Maybe their character absolutely loves eating apples, but no matter what, the author just can’t stop their character from eating goddamn bananas.
I don’t know about you but this process of a character changing or doing something against your will is completely ludicrous. There is simply no way that a fictional character can dictate their own actions against you, the author, their god.
Fictional characters DO become real beings though… in your head and on paper
Sure, fictional characters become real, living, breathing, walking, talking beings in our heads, in our words and in our stories. They, however, cannot make a single decision without you. For a start, they’re a floating individual or group in your head. They don’t have their own mind, like a real person. Only in their fictional world.
As a writer, you are the character. You make their decisions and you control their behaviour. So if there is any behavioural change to your character, then that’s down to you as the writer and god of your fictional universe, not the character.
It’s character personality development rather than character defiance
It happens in a story. A character’s personality, behaviour and mannerisms can change, just like a real life person’s personality changes over time. Personality change is the result from life experience. This is something that happens in the real world and fictional universe.
Imagine yourself ten years ago, think about where you were in your life and how it affected you. Were you a different person? If so, why? Maybe you weren’t as confident as you are now. Maybe you say certain phrases that you would never say now. Maybe you now like a certain food that you never liked before. It could be any kind of behavioural change, but it all dwindles down to life experience.
It’s more impressive when writers ensure their character’s personality developments from their experiences. Whether the experience is part of their backstory or are the effects of the narrative we’re following.
Why do writers say their character is defying them and doing what they want?
It’s for effect. It makes it seem to others that they’re so wrapped up in their creative world that they’re part of the universe. Or that their character has escaped their fictional world and joined them in the real world – sounds like the bloody Matrix films now.
Simply put, writers have an overactive imagination. It’s what helps us to come up with the stories we come up with.
I have all sorts of random thoughts in my day-to-day life, creating various scenarios in my head.
Picture this: I walk in the front door after work. It’s dark upstairs. “I bet there’s a axe wielding maniac up there hiding in my wardrobe,” I think to myself. I walk up the stairs anyway without turning the lights on.
I’ve said it already, but writers are gods of their fictional worlds. They’re in control of every single aspect of their world, including the development of a story and their characters. If a character swears, the writer allowed them to. If they order a pint, it’s because the author wanted them to. If they end up killing someone, it’s cause the writer allowed it.
You may not always agree with your character or condone what they do, say or think, but you created them. It’s because of you that they act a certain way or have a belief in your fictional world.
Sorry fellow writers who say their characters are going rogue, in my opinion, it’s simply not the case. It’s part of your imagination and you like the thought that your character is a real person who makes their own decisions. To some extent they do make their own decisions, but it’s down to you what decisions they make, whether it’s the right or wrong decision. But that’s part of the fun, isn’t it? Living a different life and doing things that we can’t always do in our normal lives.
We can live a different life through our characters.
Get in touch if you are a firm believer in lacking control of your characters
If you’ve ever experienced losing the control of your character and they do what ever the hell they want, get in touch. Tell us what happened!